Even putting aside the greek debt restructuring of 2012, it turns out that, unlike the death penalty, sovereign debt restructuring has not been abolished in europe. My sovereign debt class is discussing the march 2012 greek debt restructuring on tuesday afternoon. This time, the six proposed reforms which are sine qua non for greece s recovery will be nonnegotiable and. Greece must get nearly all of the debt held in private hands to take part in the swap in order to start receiving the eurbn of bailout monies that. Greece, creditors to discuss options for debt restructuring. Seven years on seems like an appropriate point at which to critique how the crisis has been handled and to assess whether policy changes will be required should it flare up again. The 1990s debt crisis in russia is a further exception, as western banks played an important role in the restructuring of sovietera debt in 1997 and, again, in 2000. View lazard will advise greece to restructure its debt. Hungary, the czech republic, serbia, bulgaria, greece and india with a portfolio of 30 assets and a strong.
Apr 24, 2019 debt restructuring is a process used by companies to avoid the risk of default on existing debt or to take advantage of lower available interest rates. The greek debt restructuring of 2012 stands out in the history of sovereign defaults. Financial crisis, government intervention, crisis management, corporate. The stanford rock center hosted a discussion on sovereign debt restructuring with two leading experts in the field. Is debt restructuring the right solution for greece. An autopsy jeromin zettelmeyer christoph trebesch mitu gulati july 20 abstract the greek debt restructuring of 2012 stands out in the history of sovereign defaults. Authors kirsten erichsen and andrew wilkinson sovereign debt restructuring. Joanna dreger why is sovereign debt restructuring a challenge. The imf is now asking eurozone membersgreeces main creditorsto accept a debt restructuring in the form of a haircut on the outstanding debt, and increase of maturity, andor a reduction of interest rates. We conclude with an assessment of the greek restructuring and its implications for ongoing and future debt crises in europe. Mar 09, 2012 greek finance minister evangelos venizelos welcomed the agreement, saying the restructuring will help greece get out of debt and revive its ailing economy. Overview, policy responses, and implications congressional research service 2 eurozone members. It generated fears of contagion and was viewed as a threat to the euro itself. Although both countries had to face similar problems restructuring an unpayable debt and improving competitiveness to enable growth and job.
Greece was required to reduce its total debt significantly in order to obtain the bailout which had been orchestrated by the socalled troika, i. To be sure, a restructuring of greek debt will not relieve the country from the painful. The greek economy, like those of so many other countries, entered a period of uncertainty as a result of the international economic crisis of 2009, and the nds hold on government appeared tenuous. This brief note focuses first on the cost greece faces in servicing its debt and then asks whether this is a manageable or a sisyphean task. Greek debt restructuring in the light of the second bailout package 11. But several key features of the greek debt stock could make this operation significantly different from any previous sovereign debt workouts.
The 2012 greek debt exchange was a watershed event in the euro area debt crisis. The greek debt crisis is the dangerous amount of sovereign debt greece owed the european union between 2008 and 2018. There is a heated debate as to whether the debt restructuring should have taken place sooner. Engineering an orderly greek debt restructuring request pdf. Debt restructuring is a method used by companies to alter the terms of debt agreements in order to achieve some advantage with outstanding debt obligations. Sep 11, 2012 the greek debt restructuring of 2012 stands out in the history of sovereign defaults. Section 4 identifies the circumstances under which a sovereign debt restructuring could be envisaged in the future according to the. Most investors in bonds went along, since the alternative would have been default. An evaluation of the french proposal for a restructuring of greek debt 3 evaluation from the perspective of the hellenic republic 11. Its time for your default and debt restructuring june 5, 2015. Second, how was the free rider problem addressed, that is, the incentive of each. Agreement on restructuring athens debt buys time to secure countrys financial future. Already weakened by losses from the global financial crisis, they were concerned about shouldering the additional cost of providing debt relief to greece. May 09, 2010 prior sovereign debt restructurings provide considerable guidance for how such a restructuring might be shaped.
Do the negotiations among eurozone finance ministers beg for a rethink of a need for a globally recognised, legal framework for debt restructuring. It achieved very large debt relief over 50% of 2012 gdp with minimal financial disruption, using a combination of new legal techniques, exceptionally large cash incentives, and official sector pressure on key creditors. In the absence of a legal framework for sovereign debt restructurings good faith negotiations are a key part of ensuring an orderly restructuring. Request pdf engineering an orderly greek debt restructuring for some months now, discussions over how greece will restructure its debt have been constrained by the requirement that the deal be. Benefits and costs of corporate debt restructuring.
Debt rescheduling also described as bailout, in the. Rock center restructuring sovereign debt in the 21st. For some reason, people think a sovereign default, and a subsequent debt restructuring such as greeces government faces, is something that is conceivable. It achieved very large debt reliefover 50 percent of 2012 gdpwith minimal financial disruption, using a combination of new legal techniques, exceptionally large cash incentives, and official sector pressure on key creditors. Earlier this month, the imf which was urging for more austerity and describes athens debt as unsustainable, called for significant debt relief to stop greeces debts becoming explosive. Section 3 provides an appraisal of the main features of the euro cac developed pursuant to the esm treaty. Eisner the walt disney company 500 south buena vista. Recessionled policies use sovereign debt as means to secure austerity strategies and further reinforce neoliberal reforms throughout europe. This paper argues that a deep haircut up front, under threat of legislative action, would have been seen as unnecessary and deeply coercive. Next, we analyse the last act for now, the december 2012 bond buyback. Because of a lack of trust in greece s ability to repay its debt, two programs were organized that provided financial assistance to greece. Since independence in the 1830s, greece has been in a state of default about 50% of the time. Nevertheless, despite the imf staffs determination that greek public debt could not be considered sustainable with high probability, sovereign debt restructuring was not made part of the first financial assistance package.
Approaches to corporate debt restructuring in the wake of financial crises prepared by thomas laryea in collaboration with an interdepartmental working group authorized for distribution by sean hagan january 26, 2010 jel classification numbers. Greece has exited its bailout programme, to much rejoicing. The greek operation was one of the largest sovereign debt restructuring in history4, paralleled only by the exchange set up by argentina in 20045. But there are lessons to be learned not only by greece, but also by the eurozone leadership. For some months now, discussions over how greece will restructure its debt have been constrained by the requirement that the deal be voluntary. Approaches to corporate debt restructuring in the wake of. Imf wont fund greek bailout until it gets more clarity on debt restructuring. Highly indebted greece needs a soft, voluntary restructuring of its debt, said jeanclaude juncker, the head of the group of countries using the euro as a common currency. The 2012 greek debt restructuring is a recent case where a small number of creditors were able to hold out from a restructuring even in the presence of cacs. Market impact thanks to the debt restructuring news, the 10year greek government bond yields headed to a. Certain official measures executed during greeces state debt restructuring process and the subsequent private sector involvement were not covered by existing isda provisions for cds contracts, as the international monetary fund conceded 33.
It concludes by reflecting on the political implications of the new governments announced intentions and whether these are being taken into account in the current debate over debt restructuring. The eurozone sovereign debt crisis began in the spring of 2010. What are the limitations to the greek sovereign debt restructuring. Reform and restructuring costas meghir, dimitri vayanos and nikos vettas 1 greeces public debt reached 142% of gdp in 2010 and is projected to rise to 160% in 2012. Greece has succeeded in pushing through the biggest sovereign debt restructuring in history, with 85. In particular, there are a number of lessons to be learned from the greek debt restructuring of 2012. How is the worlds mass homeworking experiment going. Part iii considers three recent shocksargentina, greece, and ukraineand what they reveal about the.
It achieved very large debt relief over 50 per cent of 2012 gdp. Greece and its creditors are expected to discuss ways to restructure the countrys debt ahead of a meeting of euro zone finance ministers on may 22, a european official told cnbc on tuesday. This is because the government is still running a deficit and because gdp is shrinking. In early 2012, greek debt restructuring took place. This column discusses the lessons from this historically unprecedented episode. The greek debt restructuring of 2012 stands out in the history of sovereign. Sovereign debt is a serious issue in most ea economies. It achieved very large debt relief over 50 per cent of 2012 gdp with minimal financial disruption, using a combination of new legal techniques, exceptionally large cash incentives, and official sector pressure on key creditors.
Jun 01, 2011 the complexity of european politics should prevent any reprofiling of greek debt this year, according to a political analyst, but markets are still waiting for any sign of a prospective default. A massive amount of sovereign debt restructuring has in fact occurred in europe since the crisis began in 2010 but the losses have not been visited on commercial creditors. Ideally, greece s government will be able to reduce the overall debt load, now around 192%, to something manageable, perhaps around 50% of gdp. It was a voluntary haircut accepted by the private holders of greek bond debt that excluded the debt held by the public sector, in particular the substantial amount of. In 2010, greece said it might default on its debt, threatening the viability of the eurozone itself. John milios, chief economist, syriza, greece ludger schuknecht, director general, federal ministry of finances, germany hernan lorenzino, ambassador of argentina to the eu interviewed. The greek restructuring took place in the form of a socalled private sector involvement psi. Corporate financial restructuring new york university.
The magic here was in significant part the product of lee buchheits genius. This presentation includes estimations and forecasts of the company in connection with the companys debt restructuring and its implications on the companys operations and its ability to repay its debt towards its creditors. A key component of greeces economic reform programme is a reduction in the countrys debttogdp. The case of greece 4 the principal at the end of maturity of the bond can similarly be cut or delayed. In the context of sovereign debt crisis, private sector involvement psi refers, broadly speaking, to the contributions or efforts of private sector creditors to the crisis resolution process, and, specifically, means that the private sector shares some of the costs of a financial crisis by incurring itself financial losses. Pdf this article analyses three seminal instances of bondholder litigation before german municipal courts following the greek sovereign debt. I will later argue in section 4 that the greek debt restructuring was actually. The country has 7 billion of debt payments due this july, which it wont be able to meet unless it receives new funds or carries out restructuring.
The greek debt restructuring and property rights a greek. Sovereign debt restructuring and debt mutualisation in the euro area. Jun 05, 2015 for some reason, people think a sovereign default, and a subsequent debt restructuring such as greece s government faces, is something that is conceivable the proverbial asteroid hitting the. According to a dataset from the national bureau of economic research, there have been at least 153 sovereign debt restructurings since 1980. This was followed by a debt restructuring that provided debt relief to greece through a combination of lowering interest rates, lengthening debt maturity, and rebates on interest and principal. The timing and design of the restructuring left money. Greeces new debt restructuring plan hear it from the experts let our global subject matter experts broaden your perspective with timely insights and opinions you cant find anywhere else. When the expenditures of a government are more than its tax revenues for a prolonged period, the government may enter into a debt. Greece attempted to restructure 206 billion of debt, of which 21. Greece plans to hire rothschild as debt adviser rt. For some months now, discussions over how greece will restructure its debt have been constrained by the requirement that the deal be voluntary implying that greece would continue debt service to any creditors that choose retain their old. It stands out in the history of sovereign defaults. All banks in europe feared that greek debt relief would set a precedent.
The greek governmentdebt crisis was the sovereign debt crisis faced by greece in the aftermath of the financial crisis of 200708. Banks had mistakenly assumed all government debt is risk free. Lessons for the eurozone from the greek debt crisis. Gdplinked securities can provide real value in future restructurings. In particular, it analyzes neither the causes of the. Pdf on jan 1, 2011, kern alexander and others published sovereign debt restructuring in the. The 2012 greek debt restructuring was the largest one in the history of sovereign defaults. After the biggest debtrestructuring in history, in which securities totaling about 200 billion euros suffered losses, greeces tradeable debt is now just 67. The greek government debt crisis was the sovereign debt crisis faced by greece in the aftermath of the financial crisis of 200708.
If it is 1%, it falls to 126%, 2% is 114% and 3% is 104%. It achieved very large debt relief over 50% of 2012 gdp with minimal financial disruption, using a combination of new legal. New york cnnmoney greece announced friday that its privatesector creditors will take part in a historic restructuring of the governments debt, setting the stage for the nation to secure. Kamenis is enrolled in a master of arts degree mald specializing in international finance and economics at the fletcher school of law and diplomacy, tufts university. It achieved very large debt relief over 50% of 2012 gdp with minimal financial disruption, using a. Sovereign debt restructuring in europe buchheit 2018. They had lent to the greek government on the questionable assumption that it had sufficient capital to absorb a greek default. The greek operation was one of the largest sovereign debt restructuring in history4, paralleled only by the. In an attempt to reinforce his governments efforts to right the economy and seeking to shore up his position within his own party, karamanlis called. European bank for reconstruction and development and cepr.
For some reason, people think a sovereign default, and a subsequent debt restructuring such as greeces government faces, is something that is conceivable the proverbial asteroid hitting. Greek debt restructuring of 2012 achieved very large debt relief with minimal financial disruption, using a combination of new legal techniques, exceptionally large cash incentives, and official sector pressure on key creditors. An estimation for korea prepared by jae chung and lev ratnovski1 authorized for distribution by kalpana kochhar october 2016 abstract the paper offers a method to quantify benefits and costs of corporate debt restructuring, with an application to korea. Dec 14, 2019 the greek debt crisis is the dangerous amount of sovereign debt greece owed the european union between 2008 and 2018. Greece completes 30bn debt swap as it eyes return to bond market leverage our market expertise expert insights, analysis and smart data help you cut through the noise to spot trends, risks and. Engineering an orderly greek debt restructuring by g. Under imf staff projections, greeces interest payments on public debt will amount to 8. Giddy corporate financial restructuring 15 dear michael, february 11, 2004 mr. Biggest debt restructuring in history buys greece only a. An evaluation of the french proposal for a restructuring. While greece is not debt free in ten years, its debt level is much safer, even in a low growth environment which. Debt crisis is a situation in which a government nation, stateprovince, county, or city etc. Debt restructuring puts greece etf in focus may 27, 2016. Second, how was the free rider problem addressed, i.
64 193 844 448 754 836 108 1511 1168 1486 36 185 687 449 624 1312 1493 704 269 1549 791 887 1360 399 577 1202 334 329 616 1433 1021 943 389